Hysterical Fiction: A Review of The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane by Katherine Howe
This was a book that, at first glance, I really wanted to like. The cover was beautifully designed, with praise from some well-known authors. However, judging this book by the cover would be far too generous. As soon as you begin reading, you’re welcomed into a predictable, played out plot stolen from countless young adult novels, with characters much the same. Connie, our heroine, brings little to offer, only doing what is precisely expected of her by the reader: stumbling blindly forward, acting without any depth or substance, and shockingly little common sense, for an allegedly educated main character.
The writing, however, separates it from the painfully generic young adult novel it so desperately craves to be. Katherine Howe uses unnecessarily long, drawn out phrases with atrociously florid language, to describe minute and unnecessary details that add little to the quality of the story.
“At least,” you might be thinking, “she’s historically accurate, right?” You would be sorely wrong, my friend. The historic segments vary from ‘decently researched’ to ‘complete nonsense’ fairly regularly, only serving to push plot points home that had already been made obvious by the events in the present.
Ultimately, this first novel fails to live up to its literary praise, and utterly disappoints those in search of a strong or interesting female lead. Additionally, the plot and writing form up what is essentially an overdressed one-off teen novel, pretending to be a serious work of literature. Overall, I’d have to give it two stars, for effort.